Jen Pollock Michel and her family opened their home to the kind of man the rest of the world shuns. While growing up he had been abused emotionally and sexually. The trauma led to addiction; the addiction led to crime. He couldn’t keep out of prison. He needed help. He needed Jesus.

“We understood the power of Christian hospitality to tangibly express the love of Jesus,” Michel writes in her new book, Keeping Place: Reflections on the Meaning of Home, “and we believed that by God’s renewing, inhabiting Spirit, this man could be granted the power to change. He needed a home, and we had one to share.”

It’s a beautiful story. Right up until the part where the man attempted to prey on one of Michel’s five children. The tragedy unfolded on Christmas Eve; thankfully, he was prevented from acting on his intent. Against all evidence, the man claimed innocence. Michel’s family no longer welcomes him into their home.

Don’t expect the warm glow of Thomas Kinkade to blur the hard truth of home in Michel’s account. Instead, Michel—previously the author of Teach Us to Want [review]—offers an unexpected apologetic for the Christian faith through our experience with home. From various angles she evokes the reader’s longing for home, a place of welcome, safety, honesty, and shelter, but she won’t allow us to invest any home on earth with hope that can only be secured by Jesus Christ. Yes, it’s good that you want to go home, she assures us. And yes, the Bible promises us we will get what we want.

But not in this place, not until Jesus returns or calls us home.

“Home isn’t yet fully restored to humanity,” she writes, “but humanity, through the sonship of Jesus, our faithful elder brother, is restored to the family of God.”

Difficulties of Home

Michel is most vivid when describing her own mixed experience with home. As the child of a working mother, Michel always wanted more of her mother’s energy and attention. But in writing about her own experience as a stay-at-home mom, she says, “Every day struck with tsunami force, and only by running full speed did I think I could outwit the daily violence.” Home, then, is hardly the refuge depicted inside lifestyle magazines.

Keeping Place: Reflections on the Meaning of Home

Keeping Place: Reflections on the Meaning of Home

IVP (2017). 237 pp.
IVP (2017). 237 pp.

Her historical account of domesticity offers instructive context. She explains why the home has never been the exclusive domain of women’s work: for simple survival, both men and women fed and clothed and cleaned. More modern factors led us to associate domesticity with despair. As the interstate highway system enabled the growth of suburbia, commutes to work and even to see friends and family lengthened. When couples left cities and farms for suburbia, they lost dense, multigenerational networks of family and work. No wonder the women were so lonely at home as the men worked downtown.

“Women, cloistered in empty homes through long stretches of daylight, suffered from the lack of human contact,” Michel writes, “which they originally had enjoyed when home and work were organized more communally.”

While Michel addresses the plight of stay-at-home moms, she doesn’t see their experience as normative or prescriptive. Not everyone has the means to support a large family on one salary, nor can everyone afford to make a home in one place for a lifetime, or even for a long time. Refugees fleeing war today don’t want to leave home; neither did racial minorities fleeing oppression last century, but staying home meant despair, even death. The concept of home evokes powerfully personal images, and it can’t be standardized across cultures and circumstances.

Mundane Mystery

Probably the most powerful section of Keeping Place concerns marriage, especially in middle age. Home has become familiar, mundane. The honeymoon has long since been consigned to dusty photos in an upstairs bedroom closet. The world, the flesh, and the Devil have conspired against us. Indeed, we can all look back and confess with Michel that we could never have understood at the wedding altar the true meaning of “in sickness and in health.”

“Marriage in the middle years is a cantering horse: you try not to get thrown,” she writes. “In marriage’s middle years we have to find joy in the everyday miracle of keeping our promises. We must keep at the repetitive, routine work of I do.”

We’re on our way to glory, learning obedience with every halting step that brings us home to Jesus.

So where can we find hope when home fails to deliver wedded bliss?

“The mystery of marriage isn’t its limitless capacity for securing our personal happiness,” Michel explains. “The mystery of marriage is its witness to the eternal, self-sacrificing love of Jesus for his bride, whom he intends to purify and present holy and blameless, without spot or wrinkle.”

Not Just Passing Through

Home is bound to disappoint because we’re prone to wander, prone to leave the God who loves us. Adam and Eve distrusted God’s good provision of home, so he banished them from the Garden of Eden. Nowhere, however comfortable and safe, has ever felt quite like home for humanity since then.

But that’s not the end of the story. We can go home again.

“Through the atoning sacrifice of Jesus Christ,” Michel writes, “our slow-to-anger, compassionate God makes a way back home.”

Until then, we toil. And sing. And open our home to strangers, even though we know the risk.

No, this world isn’t our home, but we’re not just passing through. We’re on our way to glory, learning obedience with every halting step that brings us home to Jesus.