It took a while, but I finally finished plodding through Fyodor Dostoevsky’s Demons (translated as Devils in the Michael Katz edition I’m reading, also known as The Possessed). I plodded, because that’s the only pace that makes sense when tackling one of those doorstop Russian novels that can be both exhilarating and exhausting. It took 400 pages before the story started getting interesting! As much as I love Dostoevsky, this wasn’t Crime and Punishment or The Brothers Karamazov.
In the end, one theme pressed itself on me—one with serious implications for theological study. A little theology can be dangerous. Little in the sense of being too small, too light, too thin to bear weight. And little in the sense of having enough learning to feel proud but not enough to be humbled.
A little theology tempts us to confuse theological knowledge with moral virtue. And that’s a big mistake.
When Learning Outpaces Moral Seriousness
In “The Dangers of a Little Learning,” Aaron Alexander Zubia makes the point that a classical education that sharpens the mind without forming the heart can turn great ideas into dangerous playthings. The result is brilliance without moral gravity and intellectualism without wisdom.
Zubia turns to Dostoevsky’s Demons to illustrate the point. When truth, goodness, and beauty are treated lightly (or worse, wielded for performance’s sake), ideas lose their authority, society loses its bearings, and villains rush to fill the void. A great education, Zubia reminds us, doesn’t in itself produce moral virtue.
Reading great books does not necessarily make you a good person. In fact, a classical education that ignores the development of character—that treats ideas as airy abstractions and debates as mere occasions for the display of mental prowess—can result in serious malformation.
History bears this out. Stalin read Shakespeare. Hitler admired Don Quixote. Mao memorized and composed classical poetry. Mussolini appreciated Dante. None of them lacked exposure to the great works of human imagination. What they lacked was the moral formation to receive beauty as a summons to humility rather than a tool for domination.
Playing with Big Ideas
Demons dramatizes what happens when young people play around with ideas without appreciating their weightiness. The novel shows “the dangers of developing minds that can articulate—and argue for—any point, while failing to form hearts that lovingly cling to truth, goodness, and beauty.” Another danger Dostoevsky describes is the temptation to use big ideas to cultivate a personal brand, to signal sophistication, to maintain elite status as someone “in the know.”
The intelligentsia, in Dostoevsky’s telling, isn’t driven by the pursuit of truth so much as by the maintenance of prestige. The educated want to keep up with the latest fads. They grab on to whatever ideas happen to confer cultural capital. Ideas become props in a performance. And, Zubia says, “the performative misuse of ideas saps the life out of society, ails it, and corrupts it.”
Theological Knowledge Isn’t the Same as Spiritual Maturity
The danger Dostoevsky describes in general education applies just as well to theology. When we study theology, we aren’t merely handling concepts. We’re dealing with the knowledge of the living God. We’re probing into the holy of holies, peering into mysteries far beyond our intellectual grasp. We’re reckoning with the depth of our sin, the cost of our redemption, the gravity of divine love and justice, and the promise of new creation.
One danger of theological education is assuming that biblical knowledge is a reliable indicator of personal character or spiritual maturity. It isn’t. Theology can awaken the heart, but it can also deaden it. Doctrine can become a plaything, a sparring tool for colleagues, a way of sorting people into tribes and signaling one’s place in the inner ring.
When your soteriology or your eschatology or your sacramental theology becomes more a badge of enlightenment rather than a prodding to worship, your theology has fallen short. It has become a mask for pride rather than a source of humility. It’s entirely possible to be the most theologically sophisticated person in the room and yet have a heart cold toward God and indifferent toward others.
Formation Must Keep Pace with Instruction
Theological educators—pastors in the church and scholars in the academy alike—must be on guard against theological education that outruns character formation. Someone once remarked to me that a person holding a particular theological view couldn’t possibly be a “mature Christian.” What struck me was both the presumption (the certainty about someone’s spiritual condition) and the assumption (that Christian maturity can be measured by doctrinal precision).
No. It isn’t true. I’ve known Christians with only a rudimentary understanding of theology, yet their spiritual depth put many seminary-trained believers to shame. The widow with her mite beats the seminarian with his degree. To miss this, or worse—to be unable to see it—is already a sign of malformation.
What’s more, theological exploration can become a means of evading obedience: a way to rationalize our indifference to the poor, to shrink the circle of neighbors we’re willing to love, or to dull Scripture’s moral demands. That is when Kierkegaard’s rebuke becomes appropriate: “Christian scholarship is the Church’s prodigious invention to defend itself against the Bible, to ensure that we can continue to be good Christians without the Bible coming too close.”
Why a Little Theology Is Dangerous
Theological education must not be aimed at degrees or status. It must be suffused with wisdom and virtue because it’s ultimately ordered toward worship. When theology loses its weightiness—when God becomes manageable, debatable, or brandable—it has already gone wrong.
A lack of gravity is often the clearest sign that theology is being pressed into the service of other ends: power, reputation, influence, performance. In that sense, a little theology really is dangerous. Dangerous because it’s too thin to sustain reverence, and dangerous because it gives just enough knowledge to inflate our pride but never cultivate our sense of awe.
A little theology can be a dangerous thing.
If you would like my future articles sent to your email, as well as a curated list of books, podcasts, and helpful links I find online, enter your address.
